Interruptions and Geographic Challenges to Nurses’ Cognitive Workload: Case Study
Design Implications: From the Author(s),
“Any improvements to minimize the number of interruptions experienced by nurses will improve healthcare quality and will help ensure patient safety.”
American River Medical Commentary – “This data directly correlates to medical cart workstation usage by nursing professionals. It identifies ‘Cumbersome processes’ which the current environment of care requires nurses to monitor, manage, and maintain the power systems on their medical carts and workstations. These ‘Cumbersome processes’ are unnecessary and distract from patient care. Thus, if innovative medical cart workstations reduce nurses’ travel paths and eliminate unnecessary interruptions enhanced patient care will be achieved which positively impacts better patient outcomes.”
“I contend available (geographically proximate and consistent), reliable, and abundantly powered medical cart workstations will enhance nursing work flow, elevate quality of patient care, reduce work place risk injury, and improve work place satisfaction. American River Medical continues to gain momentum and stakeholder buy-in on our project to innovate medical cart workstations that embody such an environment of care, possessing infinite scalability to grow with future increasing power demands on all types of medical carts.”
Tagg Neal, President – American River Medical, LLC
Knowledge Repository – The Knowledge Repository is a free user-friendly library of design resources that continues to grow with the latest research. Thank you to The Center For Health Design for making the KR free and available to all for the advancement of better healthcare. See bottom of this article for more information and a link to the KR.
Interruptions and Geographic Challenges to Nurses’ Cognitive Workload
*2009 Key Point Summary by: Terri Zborowsky
- Redding, D.
- Robinson, S.
Journal of Nursing Care Quality;
From: Knowledge Repository, The Center For Health Design
Issue 3, Pages 194 – 200
Copyright 2015 The Center for Health Design. All Rights Reserved.
OBJECTIVES This study set out to examine workload interruptions for nurses in medical-surgical hospital units, with the intent to identify methods for reducing interruptions and improving the nurses’ cognitive work efficiency.
Key Concepts / Contex – Inpatient care is fast-paced and requires nurses to constantly shift their attention to make clinical decisions and care for patients in a constantly environment. Nurses integrate complex thinking with psychomotor and affective skills to deliver interventions. This thinking is continually disrupted by interruptions and distractions, which compete for their attention and can lead to errors or omissions and potentially pose a risk to patient safety. Earlier studies estimate that each interruption reflected an operational loss and cost $95. The research methods used in this study replicated a prior study.
Methods – The study was conducted in medical-surgical nursing units at a 562-bed, tertiary care, urban hospital in the Midwest. The units comprised two medical units, two surgical units, and two cardiology units (one medical, one surgical). The units ranged from 30 beds (medical oncology) to 37 beds (cardiology surgical). Three of the units (medical, surgical, and cardiology medical) included intermediate care beds with invasive monitoring capacity.
The descriptive study included quantitative and qualitative observation techniques. Data collection tools included observations by two trained nurse faculty practitioners who tracked nurses’ paths on floor plans as well as kept field notes on the nurses’ actions and communication with others. A convenience sample of 32 staff nurses was observed during the day shift, working in six medical-surgical nursing units.
The study calculated interruption frequencies by type and qualitatively assessed subjects’ travel patterns to identify possible sources of interruptions and cumbersome processes interfering with patient care.
Findings – The study calculated interruption frequencies by type and qualitatively assessed subjects’ travel patterns to identify possible sources of interruptions and cumbersome processes interfering with patient care. Observers recorded 244 interruptions and found six major themes: (1) employees asking questions, (2) distracting peripheral conversations, (3) unavailable supplies that required the nurse to get them, (4) phone calls, (5) family questions, and (6) patient call lights.
Travel patterns also contributed to workflow interruptions. Nurses traveled frequently between patient rooms, medication carts or stations, and centralized equipment and care supplies locations, responding to requests from patients and other caregivers.
Reviewer note: This article discusses many findings relative to nursing unit design than can be represented here. Therefore, review of this article is recommended.
Limitations – This study is limited in that it was conducted at only one hospital where the system of care, operations, equipment, and staffing patterns may be unique to this environment. Further, the observations were all made on the day shift.
The observers did not enter patient rooms to avoid creating yet another distraction; thus, some interruptions may not have been recorded. Finally, it is possible that observers classified observations into different categories, despite their training.
Design Implications – Many interruptions occurred while nurses were in the process of performing intervention activities such as traveling to patient rooms, gathering supplies, preparing or administering medication, and patient teaching, creating a risk for medication error and the potential for unintentional omissions in care. As the authors note, “Any improvements to minimize the number of interruptions experienced by nurses will improve healthcare quality and will help ensure patient safety.”
The data from this study suggest that nurses’ travel paths on a unit create interruptions in their ability to carry out efficient patient care. Designers might consider the results of this study as they work with staff planning for their work flow. The End.
About the Knowledge Repository: The Knowledge Repository is a complete, user-friendly library of healthcare design resources that continues to grow with the latest research. Learn More Here
About The Center For Health Design: The Center for Health Design is a nonprofit 501c(3) organization whose mission is to transform healthcare environments for a healthier, safer world through design research, education and advocacy. Learn More Here
About American River Medical: American River Medical is a innovation, design and service company focused on medical cart and storage systems for healthcare. We embrace project based work, collaboration, and “Outside the box” thinking that offer opportunities to positively impact medical cart system solutions for healthcare. We fuse our experience to apply innovation where inefficiencies exist, and creativity to apply design improvements for medical cart system solutions. American River Medical is a certified Veteran Owned Small Business and a sought after diversified supplier for hundreds of healthcare systems. As a healthcare professional you’ve dedicated yourself to patient care. Our mission is to provide medical cart systems, services, and solutions that make your calling more meaningful, efficient and effective. True Solutions.
Download the Synopsis of the Key Point Summary from the Knowledge Repository here